Fifty covers, and the through-line is nerve. Every artist here has taken on something they had no business touching and found a way through.

What a cover is for
A good cover is not a tribute; it is an argument. The interpreter has to find something in the song the original did not use, and the risk is total — if it fails, you have simply reminded everyone of a better record.
What makes this collection work is that almost every selection takes on something canonical. These are not obscure songs being rescued; they are records people already love, being reopened.
What to listen for
D'Angelo's "Can't Hide Love" live at the Jazz Cafe in 1995 is the standout. The Earth, Wind & Fire song is already a masterclass in vocal arrangement, and hearing a twenty-one-year-old D'Angelo take it apart in front of a London audience is extraordinary.
Alex Isley's "At Your Best (You Are Love)" carries real weight — the song is an Isley Brothers record, her father is Ernie Isley, and Aaliyah's version made it famous for another generation. Three claims on one song, and she handles all of them.
Amber Mark's "Love Is Stronger Than Pride" takes on Sade and gets somewhere genuinely different. Marsha Ambrosius and Anthony Hamilton's "As" takes on Stevie Wonder, which is close to reckless.
Usher's "My Baby Just Cares For Me" is the surprise — the Nina Simone standard, sung by an artist nobody associates with that repertoire.
Eric Benét and Faith Evans' "Georgy Porgy" reworks Toto, PJ Morton's "How Deep Is Your Love" the Bee Gees, and Alicia Keys' "How Come You Don't Call Me" is Prince.
Dwele's "Open Your Eyes" returns to Bobby Caldwell by way of Common, and Terrace Martin's "What You Won't Do For Love" goes back to the same well.
Troop's "All I Do Is Think of You" and After 7's "Sara Smile" are the vocal-group entries.
Go deeper
Go to the originals. Half the pleasure of a collection like this is the comparison, and several of these source records — the Isley Brothers' "At Your Best," Bobby Caldwell's "Open Your Eyes," Earth, Wind & Fire's "Can't Hide Love" — are better known now through their covers than in their own right.
D'Angelo's Live at the Jazz Cafe is the album that recording comes from and is one of the great live soul records.
And Alex Isley is worth following independently — Luxury with Jack Dine is genuinely lovely.
Comments
Post a Comment