Fifty-two tracks for the specific state of mind where you want music that understands rather than music that cheers you up.
Moody, not sad
The distinction matters. A sad playlist wallows; a moody one holds a temperature. What is assembled here is a set of records that share a certain heaviness of atmosphere — slow-to-mid tempos, minor keys, a lot of low end, and vocals delivered with more restraint than the subject matter would suggest.
The range is the interesting part. It moves from 1970s soul to contemporary R&B to a Kendrick Lamar album track without any sense of strain, because the organising principle is emotional rather than chronological. Fifty-two tracks is roughly three hours, which is about right for the mood it is built for.
What to listen for
Ms. Lauryn Hill's "Tell Him" opens the set, which is a statement — the closing track of The Miseducation, a setting of the passage from Corinthians on love, and one of the most beautiful things she recorded.
Gnarls Barkley's "Who's Gonna Save My Soul" is the deep cut worth flagging: not "Crazy," but the better song, with CeeLo Green at his most exposed over Danger Mouse production.
Nas and Amy Winehouse's "Cherry Wine" is one of the last things she recorded, and it is a Salaam Remi production — worth noting given that he was central to both artists' careers.
Meshell Ndegeocello's "Elliptical" and Dwele's "Lay It Down" represent the neo-soul lineage. The Internet's "Hold On" and Arin Ray's "Old School" the modern one.
Kool & The Gang's "Too Hot" and Love Unlimited's "Walkin' In The Rain With The One I Love" are the 1970s anchors — the latter a Barry White production, and one of the strangest and most beautiful records of its era.
Jodeci's "Alone" is the 1990s at its most desolate.
Go deeper
Three album recommendations from this list. Meshell Ndegeocello's Bitter — possibly the saddest great record in soul music. Gnarls Barkley's The Odd Couple, the follow-up nobody listened to and the better album. Dwele's Some Kinda..., a Detroit neo-soul record that deserves far more attention.
And the general point about mixes like this: sequencing across decades only works when the curator is listening for feel rather than filing by genre. The joins here are invisible, which is the hardest thing to achieve.
A closing thought on why a mix like this works better than an algorithmic mood playlist. The machine optimises for records that sound similar; a person optimises for records that feel similar, which is a different and much harder target. That is why a 1972 Barry White production can sit next to a Kendrick Lamar album track here without either sounding out of place. Feel travels across decades. Timbre does not.

Comments
Post a Comment